New macOS icon on Cinnamon panel (current icon far right): New GNOME icon on Cinnamon panel (current icon far right): The current icon is slightly too big and doesn't quite match (different/no shadow) where the new one is more appropriate in size but is the wrong shape, Cinnamon seems to use something more akin to the macOS squircle (which you can see in the second pic, I've not been able to find the guidelines to Cinnamon icons so far) and your macOS icon actually seems to fit in better than the Linux or new GNOME one. ![]() I use Cinnamon and to be honest, neither the current nor new icons look particularly well suited. These GNOME changes I'm not so sure about if they are part of a generic "Linux" change as opposed to just for GNOME environments from what I can tell. I rarely ever use macOS so don't have much to add here but I do like it. I feel this is a good improvement, not that there seems to much in the way of cohesiveness, most of the mac icons seem a little random, even in regards to Apple's own icons. ![]() icons as I'm not a fan of the notebook style ones, not that I don't think they look great but the majority of my icons that aren't part of the overall system theme are of the same uniform size and shape. This only really addresses the square/squircle etc. I've been meaning to reply to this for a little while but just haven't got around to it. Obviously, the notebook version of the icon is more speculative, while the rounded rectangle is more conservative (based on the existing icon, just with the correct margins and corner radii).Īnyway, let me know what you think of these, too! (Even if this isn't strictly the correct forum thread for them.) The images embedded in this comment are actually all SVG already, so they're ready to edit, but the gnome-icons branch is here, and my pull request is here.ĮDIT: Here are some screenshots of the GNOME icons in context in my dock: So I quick threw together version of the Joplin icon based on it: Incidentally, the GNOME Contacts icon is styled like a notebook: Here's the basic GNOME icon (which is very similar to the previous/existing Linux icon): Also GNOME prefers rendering directly from SVG, but I don't know how the application is packaged, so I included PNG exports, as well. Gradients generally aren't used, but I stuck with the existing one for consistency. Among other things, GNOME icons use a different pixel grid they are rounded rectangles with a specific corner radius and they don't use integral drop shadows. This may be better in a different forum thread, but I actually started by tweaking the icon to fit the GNOME icon guidelines, which differ from the macOS ones. The template I used had a much more subtle (rasterized) bevel, which I dispensed with, and the old Joplin icon for macOS also had a much more subtle bevel, so bevels are not necessarily completely verboten.Īnother tweak I made, also based on the fact that the icon does not represent a physical object, was to replace the "J" glyph's drop shadow with an inner shadow, based on the example set by the macOS Apple Music icon: ![]() Also the beveling in the new icon was rasterized, so I was not able to recreate in SVG. My understanding with the macOS icon guidelines is that pseudo-3D detailing should generally only be used when a design represents a physical object. The template included a raster drop shadow, though I subsequently replaced it with the programmatic one used by the existing icon.Īt this point I discovered the updated icon from three weeks ago, and one thing I noticed (in addition to the use of the rounded rectangle outline instead of a squircle) was the use of a bevel. Because I was working with the existing SVG file, I just took the gradient and glyph and scaled them to fit the new clipping mask. I based my outline on the template provided by.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |